Fresh Baked Pies
For quicker orders, please call 304-400-6123.
Choose from these delicious varieties above from the drop down menu!
In the " Notes" section during checkout, please tell us when you want to pick up your pies during our business hours. For Holiday Pies, choose from:
Wednesday, December 22nd (choose AM or PM)
- Thursday, December 23rd (choose AM or PM)
- Friday, December 24th (CLOSING AT 3PM)
- Monday, December 27th (choose AM or PM)
Please allow 48 hours notice for all pie orders placed online. For quicker orders, please call 304-400-6123.
Not Available for Shipping. Market Pickup Only.
<< Varieties Available for Holiday Pre-Order >>
HARVEST APPLE PIE | What’s more American than apple pie? Only fresh Ida Red apples, with real sugar and a hint of cinnamon. You’re guaranteed the freshest fruit taste in every bite.
APPLE CARAMEL WALNUT PIE | We top our fresh apple pie with rich caramel and crunchy chopped walnuts for a dessert that’s decadently delicious. Just one bite and you’ll see why this apple pie is so special.
PILGRIM ST. PUMPKIN PIE | You can tell Thanksgiving is near when a line forms to buy our delicious pumpkin pie. Following a long-standing family recipe, this holiday favorite is full of pumpkin and a secret blend of spices.
SOUTHERN PECAN PIE | A rich blend of brown sugar, syrup, eggs and pecans gives this sweet custard pie its traditional southern flavor. An old-fashioned favorite, our pecan pie is always a popular choice for holidays!
- CHERRY PIE | Red cherries combined with a special sugar recipe for a pie that offers the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness.