Fresh Baked Pies
Choose from these delicious varieties above from the drop down menu!
In the " Notes" section during checkout, please tell us when you want to pick up your pies during our business hours.
For Holiday Pies, choose from:
Thursday, December 22nd (choose AM or PM)
- Friday, December 23rd (choose AM or PM)
- Saturday, December 24th (choose AM or PM Closing at 3pm)
WE ARE CLOSED CHRISTMAS DAY!!
Please allow 48 hours notice for all pie orders placed online. For quicker orders, please call 304-400-6123.
Not Available for Shipping. Market Pickup Only.
<< Varieties Available for Holiday Pre-Order >>
HARVEST APPLE PIE | What’s more American than apple pie? Only fresh Ida Red apples, with real sugar and a hint of cinnamon. You’re guaranteed the freshest fruit taste in every bite.
APPLE CARAMEL WALNUT PIE | We top our fresh apple pie with rich caramel and crunchy chopped walnuts for a dessert that’s decadently delicious. Just one bite and you’ll see why this apple pie is so special.
PILGRIM ST. PUMPKIN PIE | You can tell Thanksgiving is near when a line forms to buy our delicious pumpkin pie. Following a long-standing family recipe, this holiday favorite is full of pumpkin and a secret blend of spices.
SOUTHERN PECAN PIE | A rich blend of brown sugar, syrup, eggs and pecans gives this sweet custard pie its traditional southern flavor. An old-fashioned favorite, our pecan pie is always a popular choice for holidays!
- CHERRY PIE | Red cherries combined with a special sugar recipe for a pie that offers the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness.
- VERY BERRY PIE | Four different types of berries go into every pie. Fresh strawberries, red raspberries, blueberries and blackberries add their own distinctive flavor and sweetness in this delicious long-standing customer favorite.